Homepage

"Pressures from big platforms, AI, Publicis’s winning streak and the Omnicom-IPG mega-merger are sucking the tide out on agency group operations that are seen as subscale or unable to keep pace."

"This is where Dentsu comes in: the rationale for maintaining its international operations as-is looks difficult today. Revenues are declining, Europe has tiny operating margins compared to Japan and Asia-Pacific is negative. Tight control from Japan appears to have hampered the international subsidiaries’ potential. So you have a situation where the scale and momentum is not there for Dentsu to effectively compete with Publicis, Omnicom or WPP on a global level and its international operations seem to be a drag on an otherwise leading position in Japan."

Regulators should consider that the Telegraph has been “a stranded asset,” for several years, said Claire Enders, a media analyst and founder of Enders Analysis.

“A good outcome is that we don’t have any foreign interference,” said Tilbian of the current bid.

“It’s a case of industrial logic,” said Enders, forecasting operational synergies of £40 million to £50 million annually if a deal goes through, while the newsrooms would likely stay untouched.

“There is no other buyer than DMGT at £500 million,” Enders said, referring to the minimum requested price for the asset. “There is a face-saving dimension to this bid.”

New research from Enders Analysis shows that UK altnets increased their collective losses to GBP 1.5 billion in 2024, driven by lower ARPUs and rising operating costs. The report warns that UK altnets are suffering from an "unpayable" rising interest burden, where even the best performing networks are struggling to break even at an EBITDA level. They are failing to generate sufficient margins to cover ongoing investment in customer acquisition - leading to a constant "cash drain" for investors.

The report warns of a "worsening" short-term impact on the rest of the fibre network industry as prices fall. However, Enders Analysis expects this to speed up an "inevitable consolidation" into a sustainable wholesale market model under Virgin Media O2/nexfibre and CityFibre.

This is not a new concern; we have been debating the plight of the altnet for some time. But new figures from Enders Analysis show that altnets' overall accounting net losses widened to £1.5 billion in 2024 from £1.3 billion a year earlier. Things are getting worse.

Or as James Barford, Head of Telecoms at Enders Analysis, put it in a social media post on Monday, "failing operating models mean that understandable early stage 'start-up' losses have migrated to growing and persistent ongoing losses."

Altnet losses expanded to £1.5 billion in 2024, according to a new annual report by Enders Analysis. Research found that alternative fibre network providers faced a tough adverse conditions as earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation, and amortisation (EBITDA) losses continued while interest charges and operating costs rose sharply, but the average revenue per user fell. It stated, “The increasing interest burden [is] looking unpayable under any reasonable scenario”.

The report noted that even the best performers struggle to break even before EBITDA breakeven and there are not sufficient margins to invest in customer acquisition, “resulting in a perpetual cash drain for their investors”.

Enders Analysis have warned quite starkly about the unsustainable losses incurred by alternative network operators challenging incumbent Openreach and others on full fibre rollout. In their report titled “UK Altnets: Something’s got to give” they highlight some of the key challenges faced by altnets in the wider competitive landscape.

“Altnet losses expanded to £1.5bn in 2024, as EBITDA losses persisted and interest costs rose sharply, with ARPUs weakening and operating costs stubbornly high, and the increasing interest burden looking unpayable under any reasonable scenario.

Even the best performing altnets can barely make EBITDA breakeven, and not make sufficient margins to cover ongoing customer acquisition investment, resulting in a perpetual cash drain for their investors.

“All things lead to some sort of innate quality or relevance relative to other production markets,” says Tom Harrington, at Enders Analysis.

“You would assume that the near universality of the English language drives it – and it can’t not be helpful, but it’s more than that.”

“Everyone is already making less content and consolidation will only add to this downward trend in production volumes – nobody merges to spend more,” says Harrington.

Harrington is sceptical about how much money UK producers can make through this strategy.

“The one rule of TV is that no one knows if something will be a success, let alone if they will then buy a T-shirt,” he says.

With still way more than 100 altnets across the full length of the UK, highly respected digital media and telecom sector research firm Enders Analysis laid bare today quite how economically constrained they are, in a new report published for its subscribers and entitled UK altnets: Something's got to give. In its summary, the Enders Analysis team noted that the collective losses reported by the altnets totalled £1.5bn in 2024, “as EBITDA [earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortisation] losses persisted and interest costs rose sharply, with ARPUs [annunal revenue per user] weakening and operating costs stubbornly high, and the increasing interest burden looking unpayable under any reasonable scenario.”